Neighborhood Watch: Crime Doesn’t Pay… It Swaps

Writing this, I am still in disbelief - I shared my stepsister with another guy. I usually get her to suck my cock when we’re fighting, but I never thought I’d fuck her in front of another guy. Let me start at the beginning. Some nerd and I recently joined the neighborhood watch. He’s a real narc, but I just needed the volunteer hours. Well, not long after, we had a real case to crack. Criminals, who we dubbed “The TP Terrorists,” had been raiding the neighborhood, wreaking havoc and leaving houses and property in toilet-papery dismay! We knew these hoodlums had to be brought to justice, but when we finally captured the elusive wrongdoers, nothing could have prepared us for who was beneath the masks. Our fucking stepsisters! Now, the power was all in our hands. We took them back to the house and gave them a deal that was easy to understand. Either they wrap those sweet little lips of theirs around our cocks, or we can let the justice system decide what to do with them. Of course, they folded, and before I knew it, I had two girls sucking my dick. Things got weird fast. That nerd was balls deep in my stepsister, and vice versa. Who knew the TP Terrorists were such little sluts…